Using Wireless Battery-free AGVs in Manufacturing
Advantages of Inductive Power Transfer
Automated Guided Vehicles (AGVs) are not just for delivery and logistics applications. They’re playing an increasing role as main assembly line conveyances. A key enabling technology permitting AGVs to perform in the heavy duty world of production line manufacturing is Inductive Power Transfer (IPT®), also known as wireless power. This enables AGVs to abandon the battery and operate continuously without need for recharging or risk of down time due to dead batteries.
AGVs have long been used for delivery and material handling in logistics and warehouse applications, where the classic battery powered AGV is ideally suited to operate. An overnight charge is usually sufficient to permit operations through the entire work day, and there frequently are enough stopping points (and times) to permit opportunity charging. However the higher duty cycle demands in production and continuous assembly line operations do not easily permit opportunity charging. Battery operated AGVs have often failed to perform especially in 2 and 3 shift operations. The main limiting factor is the energy storage capability of the AGV battery.
Eliminate the battery
Sure, the AGVs could have bigger batteries, but that adds cost and weight to each AGV, and they still need to be charged. That requires available ‘dead time’ for the AGVs to be parked for charging. Another solution is to add additional AGVs to the system and always have some offline in a charging station, but that is an extra cost too. Assembly line AGVs tend to be larger and more expensive than delivery AGVs, with additional features such as tooling plates, lifts and fixtures. Getting battery operated AGVs to operate through a two shift production cycle can be a challenge. Getting them to operate continuously through 3 shifts is not practical. However, by eliminating the battery, the AGV is freed from its energy constraint. Wireless power supply permits the AGVs to operate continuously, without ever needing to stop for a charge, just as if they were ‘plugged in’, but without the plug.
Wireless data communication for machine control has proven to be robust and stabile in even the most demanding manufacturing environments, including automotive. Wireless data is not only being used for monitoring and data acquisition, but also for machine control and safety monitoring, with multiple devices that are rated to transmit safety signals via wireless and meet safety and security standards. However, wireless power supply enables the ‘cord’ to be cut completely so the AGV can operate automatically and indefinitely.
Assembly line operation
One advantage of logistics AGVs is their ability to free roam over large distances in a warehouse or on a factory floor. Their travel paths are flexible. There are typically a small number of AGVs covering relatively large distances, delivering material from one location to another. On-board energy storage in the form of a battery is ideal for this application. Production or assembly line AGVs, on the other hand tend to have much more clearly defined paths since they need to interface with tooling or defined workstations and also frequently engage with other conveyors such as overhead EMS or power-and-free.
There are also typically a larger number of AGVs on assembly lines, and the routes tend to be shorter. So, there is a higher density of AGVs on the assembly line, and they are always on the go. These distinct characteristics of assembly line AGVs place unique demands on the power supply system for the conveyance, which wireless power is able to fulfill.
AGVs offer a number of advantages as an assembly line conveyance compared to more traditional such as chain based conveyances. Some of the key features are:
- Operationally AGVs offer the advantages of cleanliness, low noise, improved sustainability, a safer work environment, improved operator access to the product and increased load capacity. The conveyance does not get in the way of the product.
- Installation of battery-free AGVs is much quicker, less expensive and far less risky than installation of chain conveyor systems. The installation does not require any pits, trenches, rails or structural steel. The installation consists of cutting two shallow slots in the concrete floor and inserting cable. The slots are filled with epoxy, resulting in a smooth flat floor.
- The risk at installation is reduced because all the AGVs can be tested and debugged off site beforehand. A traditional Power and Free or EMS (Electrified Monorail Conveyor) needs to be tested and debugged on site (unusually during a July or year-end shutdown) under high pressure within a tight schedule.
- AGVs can operate in a number of different modes, either as an indexing line, or a continuously moving line. They even provide the flexibility to operate differently within different zones, changing speeds, index spacing, and stopping locations based on the AGV and the product it contains. These are all reconfigurable by software without any physical hardware changes required.
- The financial advantages of AGVs include the fact that the investment is portable. Compared to a traditional conveyance where 75% to 80% of the conveyance is infrastructural, with battery-free AGVs only the wireless power supply cables in the floor are tied to the building. About 90% of the capital investment can easily be relocated. The investment is scalable. It is easy to phase in more AGVs as capacity growth requires, without the need for full scale capacity investment at the outset. The investment is flexible. Expanding or modifying the conveyance to accommodate different configurations and products is easily accomplished by changing the number of AGVs, the AGV paths, or the AGV tooling. In contrast, a typical chain conveyor would need to be almost entirely replaced.
- There is significantly less maintenance and downtime associated with battery-free AGVs, resulting in better utilization of the equipment and reduced maintenance labor and material costs.
- Greater sustainability is achieved with wireless AGVs, since they don’t require batteries, and require significantly fewer raw materials than chain-based conveyance. They also don’t require any toxic chemicals for maintenance other than occasional lubrication for wheels.
Energy and Power
Electric Power is the rate of Energy consumption per unit time (E=P*t). Power consumption of 1 kilowatt for one hour is equivalent to 1 kilowatt-hour (kWh) of Energy consumption. The main challenge for AGV batteries is typically Energy, not Power. Is there enough energy in the batteries to keep the AGV running all day, rather than is the battery powerful enough to handle the heaviest load? When the batteries are eliminated from the AGV, and it is powered wirelessly from the floor, then the primary focus becomes Power. For example, what is the peak power required to accelerate my fully loaded AGV, and is my inductive power pickup sized appropriately? For the battery operated AGV the focus is to provide the AGV with sufficient Energy to sustain the average power consumption over the required number of operating hours. When designing battery-free AGVs, the focus is on providing the AGV with sufficient peak power capability to handle the heaviest load at the highest speed.
Therefore, when sizing wireless power systems, a lot of attention is paid to the electrical power requirements, not only of each AGV, but of the system as a whole. There is a big difference between an asynchronous stop-start (workstation) assembly line, a continuously moving assembly line, and a synchronous indexing assembly line. Synchronous indexing usually has the highest peak power requirement since all the AGVs accelerate simultaneously, while asynchronous stop-start usually has the lowest system power requirement since only a few AGVs are ever moving.
So, when sizing an IPT® system, the peak and average power requirements of the individual AGVs need to be considered, and also the peak and average power requirements of the combined system whereby the duty cycle and simultaneous factor of the AGVs is taken into account.
Inductive Power Transfer (IPT®)
Inductive Power Transfer (IPT®) technology has been commercially available since the 1990’s. It is capable of transferring power in the kW range. The basic principle is the same form of electromagnetic induction used by conventional transformers. However, in this case instead of tightly wound (and closely coupled) coils on a shared magnetic core, the primary and secondary windings are separate and may move with respect to one another. Nonetheless, an alternating current in the primary conductor induces an alternating current in the secondary with which it is (albeit loosely) coupled by magnetic field. In order to make this process practical, the operating frequency is increased to 20 kHz. This reduces the size of the components since the energy density is increased in proportion to the frequency, in the same way that aircraft use 400 Hz frequency in order to reduce the size (and weight) of their electrical equipment. In addition, IPT uses tuned resonant coils in order to improve the coupling.
Contrary to popular hearsay, loosely coupled inductive power systems are more efficient that battery-powered systems. The efficiency of the inductive coupling between primary and secondary in an IPT® system is in the order of 96%. This is much better than batteries, which are typically only able to return 80% of the charging energy applied.
Chain conveyors have been around for over a century. The first conveyor systems used in the mass production of automobiles were chain conveyors. It is unlikely that chain conveyors will completely disappear from automotive manufacturing any time soon.
Battery powered AGVS have been used for many years, however primarily in material handling rather than as assembly line conveyances. Battery induced limitations (battery life, charging, disposal, required infrastructure) make then less attractive for assembly line applications.
Battery-free AGVs, powered and controlled completely wirelessly have the ability to operate indefinitely, sustainably, with minimal maintenance, and lower risk of down time. This coupled with the inherent system flexibility, and reduced cost and risk at installation means that they have found acceptance as assembly line conveyances, even in the most critical of all automotive applications, the marriage (of body and chassis).
Battery-free AGVs have established their place among assembly line conveyances providing a good return on investment (ROI) with low total cost of ownership (TCO).
We would like to thank RedViking for providing a great deal of the background information and application photographs for this article.